Join Dataflo @ SaaS Insider's India 2022 on May 26 - 27
Register Now

Email CTR vs CTOR: Which Metric Gives Better Insights?

Explore the dynamics of Email CTR vs CTOR. Discover how these metrics influence your email marketing success and ways to improve them.
Pravinan Sankar
Pravinan Sankar
Jun 1, 2023

Table of Contents

Show table of contents
Hide table of contents

Despite the fast-paced evolution of digital marketing strategies, email continues to stand strong as a reliable medium for reaching the right target audiences. 

The reason? The number of active email users is projected to hit a staggering 4.6 billion by 2025, and an astonishing 376.4 billion emails are expected to be sent each day worldwide. This enormous reach has led 81% of small businesses to depend on email as their primary customer acquisition channel, and 80% of businesses utilize it for customer retention.

Yet, successful email marketing is more than just dispatching messages and hoping they hit the inbox. It requires a deep understanding of critical metrics that gauge the effectiveness of your campaigns. 

Two such metrics, the Email Click-Through Rate (CTR) and Click-To-Open Rate (CTOR), are essential for measuring your email campaign's performance. Each provides unique insights, serving different purposes.

But the question remains: what do these metrics signify? Which one should you focus on? Is one inherently superior, or does it hinge on your campaign's context?

What is the Email Click-Through Rate (CTR)

Click-Through Rate, or CTR as it's commonly known, is one of the vital email marketing metrics that provide insights into your audience's engagement levels. Essentially, it measures the percentage of your email recipients who clicked on one or more links contained within a specific email.

To calculate the CTR, you divide the number of unique clicks your email received by the number of emails that were successfully delivered, then multiply the result by 100 to get the percentage.

Formula of Email CTR
Formula of Email CTR

Let's consider an example. Suppose you send an email to 1000 subscribers, and 50 of them click on a link within the email. Your CTR would be (50/1000) * 100 = 5%. This means that 5% of the people who received your email felt compelled to engage further with your content by clicking a link.

Looking for a better way to visualize and understand your email marketing metrics?

Dataflo's HubSpot Marketing Dashboard provides a unified platform for effortlessly tracking key performance indicators such as Emails Sent, Open Rate, and Click Rate.

Say goodbye to the hassle of toggling between multiple windows and hovering over endless streams of data.

Ready to transform your email marketing strategy?

Give Dataflo a try today!

What is the Email Click-To-Open Rate (CTOR)

While the Click-Through Rate gives you a broad view of engagement, the Click-To-Open Rate (CTOR) offers a more focused lens and provides a closer look at the effectiveness of your email content and its relevance to your audience.

The CTOR calculates the percentage of email recipients who clicked on a link within your email out of those who opened the email. It’s a measure of how compelling your email content is once a recipient has opened your email.

Here's how you calculate CTOR: divide the number of unique clicks by the number of unique opens, then multiply by 100 to get a percentage.

Formula of CTOR
Formula of CTOR

For instance, if 200 recipients opened your email and 40 of them clicked a link in the email, your CTOR would be (40/200) * 100 = 20%. This means that 20% of the recipients who opened your email were intrigued enough by your content to click a link.

CTOR is a valuable metric as it helps gauge the quality and relevance of your email content and layout. A higher CTOR indicates that your email content is resonating well with those who opened it, prompting them to engage further.

However, like all metrics, CTOR should not be viewed in isolation. Combining it with other metrics, such as the overall open rate and conversion rate, can give you a more nuanced understanding of your email campaign's effectiveness.

The Significance of CTR and CTOR in Email Marketing

Both click-through rate (CTR) and click-to-open rate (CTOR) are instrumental in assessing the impact of your email marketing campaigns. 

These metrics serve as essential indicators of how effectively your content resonates with your audience and its ability to drive meaningful engagement.

The Role of CTR

CTR is a broad metric that gives you a quick snapshot of your email engagement. 

It helps you gauge the overall effectiveness of your email campaign, taking into account the number of emails delivered, the number opened, and the number of recipients who took the action of clicking a link.

For instance, abandoned cart emails, which are a critical component of e-commerce email marketing strategies, average a click-through rate of 8.76%

This statistic underscores the importance of CTR as it highlights the potential of targeted email campaigns to re-engage customers who have shown a high intent to purchase by adding items to their cart but not completing the transaction.

The CTR metric is beneficial in understanding how your subject lines, email preview text, and the timing of your emails resonate with your audience. 

If your CTR is low, it might suggest that your subject lines aren't enticing enough to get recipients to open your emails or that the content within isn't compelling enough to prompt clicks.

Tracking your CTR over time can help you spot trends, enabling you to refine your strategy. 

For example, if you observe a noticeable increase in your CTR after making a change to your email content or design, it might be worth considering more of such changes in future campaigns.

The Power of CTOR

On the other hand, the Click-To-Open Rate (CTOR) gives you a more refined understanding of your audience's behavior post-open. 

This metric zeroes in on the effectiveness of your email content and design in driving clicks from those who have opened your email.

A high CTOR suggests that your email content and design are on-point and persuasive enough to inspire action among the readers. 

It helps you understand the relevance and attractiveness of your email content to those who have shown initial interest by opening your email.

CTOR is particularly handy for testing different types of content, design elements, and calls to action within your emails. 

Splitting your audience into segments and sending different versions of your email allows you to leverage CTOR to identify the version that generates the most engagement.

In addition, the high open rate of 43.76% for abandoned cart emails reflects the effectiveness of targeted and personalized content in capturing the interest of recipients, which is a crucial factor for improving CTOR.

Email CTR vs. CTOR: Which One Should You Prioritize

The straightforward answer is: it depends on your campaign objectives and what you want to learn about your audience's engagement with your emails.

CTR is your go-to metric when you want to understand the overall reach and appeal of your email campaigns. This metric assists in evaluating the effectiveness of your subject lines and overall campaign in generating curiosity and initial engagement. 

It's a broad measure of your campaign's success, taking into account everyone who received your email. Hence, if you're running a large-scale campaign and want to understand its overall impact, focusing on improving your CTR would be beneficial.

On the other hand, CTOR provides a more in-depth understanding of how well your content resonates with the people who actually open your emails. 

It provides you how successful you are in converting an open into a click, which can be more indicative of the quality of your email content and design. 

If your primary objective is to enhance the relevance and engagement of your emails among the people who've shown initial interest, CTOR should be your focal point.

CTR gives you a macro-level view of your campaign's performance, while CTOR provides a micro-level view focusing on post-open engagement. They both provide valuable insights and using them in tandem can give you a well-rounded view of your email campaign performance.

For instance, a high CTR coupled with a low CTOR could suggest that your subject lines are highly effective at drawing people in, but your email content might not be as engaging or relevant to the reader. 

Conversely, a low CTR and a high CTOR might indicate that your email content is compelling, but your subject lines might not be enticing enough to get people to open your emails in the first place.

Neither metric is inherently superior to the other; it's about choosing the right focus based on your specific campaign objectives and what you wish to learn from your audience's engagement with your emails. 

Boosting Your Email Marketing Performance: Improving CTR and CTOR

Here are five actionable tips to boost both your CTR and CTOR effectively:

Craft Compelling Subject Lines: The subject line is the first thing your recipient notices, and it plays a pivotal role in whether your email gets opened. Make sure your subject lines are enticing and relevant, and spark curiosity to open the email. Personalization, such as including the recipient's name or relevant details, can also enhance your email's appeal.

Use Clear and Persuasive CTAs: Your call to action (CTA) is crucial for encouraging clicks. Make sure your CTAs are clear, persuasive, and easy to find within your email. They should communicate what action you want your reader to take and what they stand to gain from doing so.

Optimize Email Design: An aesthetically pleasing email design can significantly enhance user engagement. Make sure your emails are visually appealing, easy to read, and optimized for mobile devices, as a significant portion of users open emails on their phones.

Segment Your Audience: Not all your subscribers will be interested in the same content. Segmenting your audience based on their preferences, behaviors, or demographics can help you send more targeted and relevant emails, which can improve both CTR and CTOR.

Test and Optimize: Lastly, always be testing. Conduct A/B tests on different elements of your email, such as subject lines, content, CTAs, and design layout, to figure out what works best for your audience. Use your findings to continually optimize your email campaigns and improve your performance over time.

Closing Thoughts

Fine-tuning email marketing strategies is an iterative process, requiring keen attention to audience preferences and continually refining your strategies. 

You can take advantage of the tools like Dataflo when integrated with your HubSpot Marketing Dashboard, which can be instrumental in this process, offering real-time visibility to track leads and contacts from email marketing mediums, providing another layer of insight into your email marketing effectiveness. 

With Dataflo, you can easily visualize email marketing KPIs like Emails Sent, Email Open Rate, and Email Click Rate in one unified dashboard, saving you the hassle of switching between multiple windows.

And, Dataflo's paid attribution feature gives you a comprehensive overview of your campaigns' performance, helping you understand where your marketing efforts yield the most return.

With Dataflo, it's not just about access to data but about having relevant data at the right time in the format you need. Dataflo empowers you to devise more impactful and effective email marketing campaigns by providing an end-to-end view of your customer journey.

Get a 360 degree view of your business performance with GA4 Dashboard today
Measure user engagement on your website with Dataflo's Favourite Dashboard

Dataflo, a simple no code platform to visualise all your paid campaign metrics

Wouldn't it be nice to have a single dashboard that summarizes all your marketing efforts in one place? Check out Dataflo’s pre-built customizable dashboard for monitoring and evaluating the success of your paid marketing efforts across all your ad campaigns.

What if you get common values for Impressions, Clicks, CTR, CPC etc. for your multiple ad campaigns all under one roof?

Dataflo simplifies your paid advertising reporting with this feature. You don’t have to depend on often messy, time-consuming spreadsheets to track the most important KPIs/ metrics. No more logging into multiple accounts or hopping between different tools in the tech stack to check how your accounts on different channels are performing, or compiling a comprehensive report that seems to take eternity.

Now you can view your Facebook, Twitter and other social media performance metrics in one place.

Get started by following these 3 simple steps:

Step 1: Get our pre-built template

Step 2: Connect and integrate your PPC accounts with Dataflo

Step 3: In seconds, your dashboard will be ready to use

All your metrics inside your slack

Using Slash command in Slack, track your key metrics for a given period in just 3 clicks.

Are you a paid marketer running campaigns across multiple channels?

Identify the top-performing campaigns across multiple channels that generate revenue and conversions with Paid Revenue Attribution Template

Get Started

Pravinan is a physicist turned writer who's currently wearing the marketer's hat. A tech enthusiast by nature and an avid non-fiction books reader, he loves to explore the world around him and always keep learning new things. When he's not working on his latest project, he likes to spend his time writing Tamil poetry or finding out more about organic farming.

Get your metric right inside your slack workspace.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do CTR and CTOR differ from each other?
Which metric is more important for measuring email campaign effectiveness?
How can I improve my CTR and CTOR?
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
Subscribe to our Newsletter

Pravinan is a physicist turned writer who's currently wearing the marketer's hat. A tech enthusiast by nature and an avid non-fiction books reader, he loves to explore the world around him and always keep learning new things. When he's not working on his latest project, he likes to spend his time writing Tamil poetry or finding out more about organic farming.

Get your metric right inside your slack workspace.